College List Building Feeling Overwhelming? Let’s Fix That.


Hi, Reader!

Last week, we talked about how many schools you might want to apply to … but now you’ve got to make sure that number is a nice balance of safety, target, and reach schools.

And with college admissions changing from year to year (and seemingly moment to moment), defining those schools (and then creating a balanced list from them) can be challenging.

The ideal list includes safety schools (roughly a >70% chance of admission), target schools (30%-70% chance), and reach schools (<30% chance).

But these percentages aren’t the whole story. You’ll also want to look beyond the numbers to consider financial fit (will this school be affordable?), academic fit (do they offer programs in your areas of interest?), social fit (will you thrive in this environment?), and geographic fit (is the location workable?).

While you can definitely use the tools to compare your profile to that of accepted students, don’t underestimate the power of the “gut check.” If you can’t imagine yourself happy at a school, it doesn’t belong on the list — even with a 90% admission chance.

Remember, the goal isn’t just college admission — it’s finding places where you can flourish for four important years!

So here’s how you might start creating that list of perfect-for-you schools!

POLL: How Many Schools Are You (Maybe) Applying to?

Vote to see results!

Made with ❤️ by List Gadget

🛠️ Tools to Evaluate and Categorize Schools

1. Common Data Set (CDS)

The CDS provides detailed information about a college’s admissions statistics, including GPA, test scores, and acceptance rates.

How You Can Use It:

  • Find the CDS: Google “[College Name] Common Data Set.”
  • Review Section C: This section details freshman admissions data.
  • Compare Your Profile: Match your GPA and test scores against the middle 50% range of admitted students.

Example: If a college’s middle 50% SAT range is 1300–1450 and your score is 1350, the school might be a target.

Learn more about the Common Data Set here.

2. CollegeData.com

This platform offers tools like the Admissions Tracker, allowing students to compare their profiles with those of admitted students.

Features:

  • Admissions Tracker: See who got in where and compare stats.
  • College Search: Filter schools based on various criteria.

3. CollegeVine

CollegeVine provides personalized admissions chances and helps categorize schools into safety, target, and reach based on individual profiles.

Benefits:

  • Chancing Engine: Get customized estimated admission probabilities.
  • School List Builder: Create and organize your college list.

Remember, the goal is to find colleges where you’ll thrive academically and personally. While it’s essential to aim high, ensuring a mix of schools where admission is likely, possible, and challenging will provide the best outcomes.

📣 Register Now: The College Essay Guy’s Summer College Essay + Application Program Starts June 26

Don’t let college applications overwhelm your senior year! Join Ethan Sawyer’s Summer College Essay + Application Program and make the most of your summer!

THE College Essay Guy himself will guide you through 8 powerful sessions (held weekly, June-August) that include:

🔥 Part 1: Uncover your meaningful stories, master essay structure, and develop a personal statement that truly represents you.

🔥 Part 2: Create outstanding applications, develop your unique strategy, and write supplemental essays that make you unforgettable.

You can attend live sessions or watch recordings later — your summer, your schedule!

I attend the counselor version of his course every year — check out my personal statement from last year!

➡️ Register now

HOT TIP: You can get 10% off the course when you register with code JULIA10. And if you register using this link, forward me your confirmation. I’ll give you my “ResuMEH to ResumYAY” on-demand video course and companion guide for writing your student resume for FREE (a $127 value). (A great resume is a must if you’re asking teachers for letters of recommendation or applying to schools like UT-Austin and A&M.)

Happy Writing!

Julia

What I'm Working on

I’m booking locations for my Montgomery-area workshops this summer. Interested in a virtual version? Reply and let me know!

What I'm Recommending

Juniors shouldn’t leave school without asking for letters of recommendation from 3 teachers. Check out my blog to help ensure you get awesome letters.

What I'm Gifting

My graduation gifts always include the IKEA Frakta bag or this Amazon dupe for the same thing at a way better price!. It’s so great for packing clothes, and you can wear it like a backpack AND use it as a checked bag for airlines (though I suggest double-bagging).

Interested in Coaching? Let's Talk! | ​View My Resources | Need Help? Open a Support Ticket.

This email may contain affiliate links. This means I may receive a percentage of the sale in commission, but using these links doesn't affect the price you pay. I recommend only products I use myself and believe in. Thank you for supporting me! Read more: Privacy Policy

You're receiving this email because you opted in to my mailing list or because you're a current or past client. Don't need (or want) this information anymore? No hard feelings. Just use the links below to adjust your subscription.

  • Unsubscribe From All: To stop receiving all communication from me, including emails related to any purchases. (Coaching clients will still receive service-related emails.)
  • Unsubscribe to Newsletter: To unsubscribe from my newsletter but still receive updates on any purchases you've made.
  • Update your Profile: To fix your name or update your email address.

If a friend has forwarded you this email and you'd like to subscribe, come join the party by clicking here.

Julia Byrd: Essay Coach

I work with rising high school seniors to help them identify the meaningful, personal stories that make for standout admissions and scholarship essays. Subscribe to my newsletter to get the latest college admission and essay writing information.

Read more from Julia Byrd: Essay Coach

Hi, Reader! We’re heading into summer, and that can mean only one thing (besides essay writing): The Common App is prepping for its Aug. 1 debut! This year, the Common App is getting a long-overdue glow up to its look and feel, but much of the content will stay the same — including all seven personal statement prompts. Here’s what you need to know. 📆 Important timing: The Common App will shut down July 28 for maintenance and relaunch Aug. 1 with the new design. 💄 The visual makeover: Think of...

Hi, Reader! I’m in the thick of summer here in Texas. Pool days, vacations, and (of course) lots of essay work. After an unfortunate run-in with a copperhead under my rosemary a few years ago, I’m also trying gardening again. (If you’re not too squeamish, you can read my story here.) Some might call my little garden disorganized — a mishmash of citrus, cantaloupe, berries, and herbs — but I call it an experiment. See what grows and evolves, see what I like, and see what I crave more (and...

Confused about college choices?

Hi, Reader! Ah, the "magic number" question! If only there were just one right answer (or number). Here's my guideline: quality over quantity, always. I typically recommend 8-10 thoughtfully selected schools for most students, but there are students who apply to only 3-4 schools … and some who apply to more than 20. Now, back in the day, I applied to just two schools: Illinois Wesleyan University and DePauw University. (And no, I have no idea what I wrote my essay on, but I sure wish I had a...