Accepted… now what?


Hi, Reader!

Not that I'm trying to take all of my life advice from TikTok, but I watched a video last week about trying to find at least one good thing about each day. It doesn't have to be deep. It doesn't have to be life-changing. It just has to be good. I'm trying to do that for myself this year. Heck, it feels like we could all use something like that right now, right?

My good thing for today? I was going through a bag of old 8mm family movies I want to have converted, and I came across some pictures of my dad in his 20s that neither my sister nor I had ever seen. Some were super-silly, and while I was wistful that I can’t ask him about who he was with and what he was doing (both of my parents have passed away), they brought a smile to my face and remind me that they, too, were young once.

That moment today reminded me how much perspective matters. If I may wax poetic for a moment: Good moments don't erase the hard parts, by any stretch. But they can make space for clarity and reflection — especially during this stressful season as colleges release decisions. So I challenge you, too, to find those good things in the everyday, even when it seems hard.

Now, let's pivot to the good this week! While we talked the other week about deferrals and how to write a strong letter of continued interest, I wanted to talk about something a little more positive this week: Choosing between college acceptances (for those of you who will need to make this big decision). Yes, this can also feel a little overwhelming (especially when you're spoiled for choice among a few great options), but a strategic approach can help transform this high-stakes decision into a thoughtful, values-based process.

Here's how I might suggest you approach this decision:

  • Start by revisiting your original priorities in a school. What were you most drawn to? Academic programs, location, size, campus culture, post-graduate outcomes, research opportunities? You can now also view your list with the added dimension of financial aid packages and any outside scholarships received.
  • Consider creating a concrete comparison tool (a simple spreadsheet works well) that lists key factors for each school, including both objective measures (net cost, travel expenses) and subjective impressions (nice dorms, on-campus Chick-fil-A).
  • If possible, attend admitted student events (virtual or in-person) to experience each campus through the lens of a "future student" rather than as a "hopeful applicant." These visits often clarify preferences dramatically. Include your gut feelings as you do this — emotional connection to a campus community matters for thriving in college.
  • Parents, your role is to provide guidance on financial realities (although I hope your initial list took this into account) and ask thoughtful questions while respecting that this ultimately must be your student's decision. If they're genuinely torn between options, consider practical tie-breakers: strength in their likely major, career services resources, or geographic preferences.
  • Embrace feeling all of the emotions. This isn't always an easy decision, but we hope you can make it a smart one.

Remember that there's rarely one "perfect" choice — students can often thrive at any college where they actively engage with available opportunities. (And while I don't want to put the cart before the horse here, if it turns out not to be their right-fit school, there are options for transferring.) The goal here isn't finding the abstractly "best" college; instead, it's about finding the environment where you're most likely to grow and succeed!

As you start to get knee-deep in decision-making, I'd love to hear from you: What are your top considerations when narrowing down acceptances?

Happy Writing!

Julia

💻 What I'm Working on

I'm always looking to grow as a coach, so I just signed up for a 6-week training through Prompt on effectively coaching students. I love learning from new people with new perspectives. My years of coaching have taught me that every student works differently and thrives with different support, and I want to make sure I offer it!

✅ What I'm Recommending

Juniors: Second semester is one of your last chances to make some meaningful changes to your high school resume. Take a look at your resume, activities list, and transcript. What are some meaningful changes you can make now to strengthen your application next summer? Look to see where some gaps are (leadership? service?) and see how you can fill them in.

🎧 What I'm Listening to

STEM students might want to check out this YouTube video: "Standing Out in STEM: Practical Advice for Future Scientists, Engineers and Techies" (1:00). It includes great insights from the College Essay Guy team.

Interested in Coaching? Let's Talk! | ​View My Resources | Need Help? Open a Support Ticket.

This email may contain affiliate links. This means I may receive a percentage of the sale in commission, but using these links doesn't affect the price you pay. I recommend only products I use myself and believe in. Thank you for supporting me! Read more: Privacy Policy

You're receiving this email because you opted in to my mailing list or because you're a current or past client. Don't need (or want) this information anymore? No hard feelings. Just use the links below to adjust your subscription.

  • Unsubscribe From All: To stop receiving all communication from me, including emails related to any purchases. (Coaching clients will still receive service-related emails.)
  • Unsubscribe to Newsletter: To unsubscribe from my newsletter but still receive updates on any purchases you've made.
  • Update your Profile: To fix your name or update your email address.

If a friend has forwarded you this email and you'd like to subscribe, come join the party by clicking here.

Julia Byrd: Essay Coach

I work with rising high school seniors to help them identify the meaningful, personal stories that make for standout admissions and scholarship essays. Subscribe to my newsletter to get the latest college admission and essay writing information.

Read more from Julia Byrd: Essay Coach

Hi, Reader! In two weeks, I'll be heading out to San Diego, where I’ll spend the week with the College Essay Guy team to plan for the next admission season. I love the team I work with and am grateful to be able to spend the week with them learning, connecting, and planning. They make me a better essay coach — and person. And even though I have plenty of time before I leave, I can bet you that I'm likely to wait until the night before to start packing. Can you empathize? It seems like often,...

Hi, Reader! Happy New Year! I hope you’ve had the chance to enjoy a restful winter break with friends and family. We had the chance to take a family cruise, and we loved spending New Year’s on the ship. It’s been a busy year, so I really valued the time to relax, recharge, and read some mindless books on my Kindle — one of my favorite Christmas presents from last year. But I’m back in action (though I'm missing the all-you-can-eat-bacon) and have been seeing a lot of Facebook posts about the...

Hi, Reader! It's almost Black Friday, and you know what that means: Shopping! I’ll admit, I was doing a little post-dinner shopping last night, scoring a few deals on Etsy and a few things from my daughter’s wish list. As you're looking for the best deals out there, you might as well earn some cash back or gift cards, too. Here are my favorite deals I've been using for years! (And they're all free!) These aren’t college-related at all, but saving money is something we can all get behind as we...